Pexels vit ória santos 2087954
Money Mindset Guide

10th October 2024 · 6 minute read

Published by The Real Debt Guy

  • Budgeting
  • Luxury lifestyle
  • Debt & lifestyle

What's the Difference Between Necessities and Luxuries

Luxury vs Necessity – How to spot the difference

In today’s society, there seems to be a common misunderstanding between what is seen as a luxury and what is a necessity. This confusion is adding to the growing number of people in debt. If you’re struggling with debt and you’re looking for ways to take back control of your spending and finances, being able to spot the luxuries is a great place to start.


So, let’s start by looking at what luxury and necessity are precisely.

Not in the mood to read? We got you covered. Listen to the rest with the YouTube link at the bottom of the page.

What is a Necessity vs a Luxury?

To put it simply, a necessity is an essential need. It’s an indispensable item or service that you can’t live without.  Whereas a luxury on the other hand, is a ‘nice to have’, it’s not crucial. The problem is that people think they can’t live without certain items or certain things. But they can.

The real necessities in life are things like food, water, clothing and shelter. You might think money is a necessity, but the truth is, it isn’t. Money is a tool, nothing else. It allows you to obtain the necessities you need. You exchange it for something you can use.  Money is useless if it does not allow you to do that.

Is a luxury a necessity?

If you challenge yourself to look at your spending, you will undoubtedly find some items or expenditures for which you are torn about where to put them. If you have to think, then they will always be a luxury.

Let’s take a look at three items that are often confused as a necessity.

Is a phone considered a necessity?

No, it's not; it’s a luxury. How do we know that? People have survived for centuries without mobile phones, and they still do. The first mobile phone wasn’t even invented until 1973. Now it’s rare not to see someone with a mobile phone. The problem is that it is now considered normal to have a monthly mobile phone contract and an iPhone worth £600 plus.

People with little to their name will even skimp on actual necessities like food to ensure they have a mobile phone. Mobile phones have become a false essential, a ‘necessity’ to stay connected. This is not a natural need, but the power of marketing has convinced us of its necessity.

The truth is, we couldn’t be more disconnected. We are constantly glued to mobile phone screens instead of connecting with the people around us. Take the mobile phone away; you can still communicate with people.

Is a car a necessity?

This one isn’t as black and white. By itself, a car is a luxury.  However, if it is the only way to obtain a necessity, then you could say it is 'a necessary means to a necessity’...without it, you may be in trouble.

You might need a car, but do you need a brand-new BMW? The minute you’re looking at taking out car finance, that car becomes a luxury. It’s something you cannot afford without the help of finance.

The costs of taking on car finance and running a car can be significant and can seriously eat into your income. Even if you consider a car a necessary means to a necessity, there's still a thin line between it being a  necessity and straight-up luxury.

What about alcohol and cigarettes?

They are both luxuries; neither are essential for survival and are detrimental to your health. People who don’t smoke 20 cigarettes a day or drink every night will more than likely be in better health than those who do. These items are pretty much the opposite of a necessity!

If you are addicted to alcohol or cigarettes, you can seek free help and support from your doctor, who can refer you.

The above are just three examples of commonly misjudged luxuries that people claim they cannot live without, but the list goes on.

Need not want

Today's businesses are incredibly skilled at making you believe a luxury item is necessary. They influence you from something being a want (a luxury) to a need (a necessity).

Take the internet, for example. It has only been around since the early eighties. Yet today, the minute the internet ‘goes down,’ we go into a blind panic! How will I order my Deliveroo?! Gone are the days of picking up the phone, ordering Chinese food, and walking to collect it! We’ve all become accustomed to having anything we want at our fingertips and have been conditioned to feel we need it to survive.

Think about how often you’ve heard someone say: ‘I need a new washing machine, mine is broken’, ‘I need a new TV, mine is old’, ‘I need a new phone, mine has been playing up’. The key word here is need, not want. The truth is none of these are essential for survival. However, they are seen as a social norm that makes life easier or a source of entertainment. They are a want that people have become so dependent on that they genuinely feel like they need them.

Remember to read The Real Debt Guy's final thoughts below!

The Real Debt Guy is a qualified financial adviser and a UK debt expert. The information in this article is considered to be true and correct at the publication date..

The Real Debt Guy's final thoughts.

If you are serious about cutting back on your luxury expenditure, challenge yourself to decide what you need, not what you want. If you can survive without what you have identified as a need, it's a want. These things may improve your life but are not essential for survival.

A simple rule to follow is to ensure that any luxuries you buy are paid for with money earned with little or no effort, e.g., passive income.

Let’s take investments as an example. If you want to have a super expensive luxury holiday every year, it’s much better to have rental property income to cover the cost rather than putting the holiday on a credit card. You’ll only have to work harder to pay it off, which takes away from the purpose of the holiday in the first place.

If you find yourself working into the ground to afford the luxuries in your life, something has got to give. The truth is that having more and more luxuries will not necessarily make you happier. People with the most simple of lives are often the happiest.

Challenge yourself today to see the absolute necessities in your life.

If you want to take control of your spending and finances, check out our Budget Planner to get a head start. You might also find it interesting to check out our mindfulness section, which challenges how you think about what you need and want.

Simplifying complicated matters.

You might also like…

Speak to us

It's good to talk! Debt can seem like a lonely place, it doesn't have to be. Join our community to interact directly with The Real Debt Guy team and other members like you. Debt is not something that you have to suffer alone. We got you.

Speak to The Real Debt Guy